Book Review: Shanghai Girls

Set in an extravagantly pseudo-Chinese neighborhood of Los Angeles in the 1930s, a "China City" that catered to white tourists by showcasing the most cutesy (and usually inaccurate) of oriental curiosities, Shanghai Girls by Chinese-American novelist Lisa See documents the hopes and disappointments of two sisters who flee Japanese war atrocities in Shanghai only to meet alienation and prejudice on the "golden mountain" of the United States.

Robert Fulford of the National Post reviews the novel, praising it for its cross-cultural examination, exploration of identity politics, and readability while criticizing its "unremarkable" prose.

Fulford writes:

Her female characters alternately support and resent each other, in ways that suggest she's tapped into the rich vein of narrative uncovered in recent decades by Chick Lit authors. At the same time, she serves as advocate and analyst of the Chinese experience; she writes Identity Fiction, running parallel to Identity Politics. She knows precisely how hard life on this continent was for the Chinese and how to spell out the damning historical evidence. Angel Island in San Francisco Bay, while sometimes called a West Coast equivalent of Ellis Island, appears in Shanghai Girls without a trace of sentiment: It's depicted as the place where Chinese would-be immigrants were harshly imprisoned while bureaucrats tried to send them back home.