Twittergate!

Alice Hoffman, the author of Practical Magic and the more recent The Story Sisters, blasted critic Roberta Silman for her unfavorable review in the Boston Globe. Writing on her Twitter account (in a post that has since been removed), Hoffman mourned the days when books were once reviewed by writers, calling Silman a "moron" and asking, "My second novel was reviewed by [Anne] Tyler. So who is Roberta Silman?"

Silman's fiction, however, has been published in The New Yorker. She has released three novels and a collection of short stories. And Hoffman's outburst has provoked only amusement from
Silman, a flood of support from readers, and an apology from Hoffman.

Silman's anger-inducing review praised Hoffman's earlier work while calling the latest novel "tired" and improvisational, a bit messy. Overall, the review was not very harsh or entirely negative.